Posted by Adam on April 26, 2017 at 11:44 PM CST
Sadly, as a result of the money that people are willing to spend on Star Wars, this often results in less scrupulous individuals selling fake items and scamming collectors to make a quick buck, or in some instances, a lot of money over an extended period of time. Read on to find out some of the major scandals over the years.

Hosts
James Gallo
Mark Salotti
Isaac Lew
Ross Cuddie
Gus Lopez

After a brief introduction and clarification that the panel, the first scandal discussed was that referred to as the Ren Hoeck Affair from early 1996, which involved somebody by the name of Brian Kettler posting misleading descriptions on early Internet text-based newsgroups that suggested he was selling vintage Kenner items. Ultimately what he sent was modern-day equivalents such as Galoob mini-ships and Bend-Ums, scamming 20-30 collectors of an estimated $5,000.

Summary of Outcome
  • Carefully crafted wording intended to deceive
  • Prices were a great deal, but not for items received
  • Scammer ignored more specific, detail oriented questions about items (does vehicle have part A, B, C)
  • Fake reference from second account
  • Scammer admitted his intent to mislead
  • Scammer claimed all buyers got items as described
  • No buyers were reimbursed or got legit items
  • Scammer did not answer specific questions
  • Collectors competing instead of collaborating and cross-checking information

The moral of the story is, if it seems too good to be true, it likely is!

Next up was the Fake "Blue Harvest" Hardcopies, which were vintage prototype hardcopies originally obtained from former Kenner employees that were passed of as authentic from 1977-1985 and involved both the 3 3/4" action figures as well as prototypes of some Micro Collection 4-ups. Involving both online and in-person sales, the scam occurred between 1993 & 1995 and has continued to spread amongst collectors and dealers since then, costing several dozen collectors a total of more than $10,000.

While hardcopies were typically cast in green (dynacast) and brown (carbalon) urethane, the fake hardcopies were cast in blue urethane (hence the name) not used during the vintage Kenner era.

As it's been 20 years since these first surfaced, the question has been asked as to whether or not these pieces have any historical value. The key point to remember is that while the Blue Harvest pieces did come from the original silicon molds, they were not used in the production process of the vintage Kenner Star Wars toy line between 1977 & 1985.

Nevertheless, some interesting pieces including unproduced Micro Collection 4-ups, 2-up 8D8 and EV-9D9 revealed small unproduced or alternate versions of certain arms/legs etc., with the moral of the story being that even Kenner employees or other first-hand sources can become corrupt and influenced by the lure of money.

Following a similar vein, the next scandal discussed was the Fake "Green Harvest" Hardcopies, which involved a collector who had been known and active within the community for several years, selling fake painted and unpainted hardcopy figures as well as wax sculpts. Sales were made both online and in-person between 2007 & 2010, and more than twenty collectors were affected, losing out in excess of $200,000. The moral of this story is that even known, well established collectors and Kenner sources can turn to the Dark Side.

The scandal first broke in April 2010 during Celebration V, with the issues that led to this being as follows:
  • Condition was too good
  • Paint color and type did not match authentic pieces
  • Material and/or color was off from originals
  • Size was not correct and details were lost or altered
  • Showed casting flaws or filling-in of foot pegs
  • Evidence of sanded-off copyright information
  • Poor pin hole placement or crooked holes

One example showed an authentic Lumat figure with a broken left ear alongside unpainted and painted figures that were both cast from the original. An overlay and color filter of the original over the fake unpainted figure demonstrated that the line of the ear break matched perfectly and showed that an attempt had been made to repair the ear on the fake figures.

Another major scandal that scammed thousands of collectors out of a significant sum of money, in this case more than $100,000, was committed by Toy Toni, who was based in the UK, but affected people worldwide beginning in the early 1990s through to 2014. Using Palitoy, German and Clipper vintage cardbacks, the scheme began in the mid-1980s, and spanned the following timeline:
  • 1986 - Palitoy factory in Coalville Closes
  • 1988-1989 - Arthur Bailey sells leftover stock to Toni
  • 1991-1992 -
    First home sealed cards sold to collectors
  • 1994 - Toni advertises in Model and Collectors Mart
  • 1997 - www.toytoni.com web site launches
  • 1998 - Toni sells on eBay under public id marsking
  • 1999 - Toni buys on eBay under private id t489ab
  • 2000 - AFA is formed and starts grading Toni's
  • Mar 2008 - UKG is formed and starts grading Toni's
  • Dec 2013 - Exposed by Jason Joiner on SWFUKK forum
  • Jan 2014 - Home sealed cards withdrawn from sale

Between 2000 and 2013, AFA graded over 2000 Toni's, while there is no population report available from UKG, but the number is approximated at close to 1000 figures. Toni's defence was first to blame others, such as Arthur Bailey (who died in the mid 2000s) and Jason Joiner who exposed him on SWFUK, then deny everything and ultimately say nothing.

Fake coins are nothing new, so it likely comes as no surprise to learn that fake POTF coins have been distributed over the years, with four different suspected recent re-strikes:
  • Thick
  • Thin
  • Normal gauge (rough-ridged)
  • High Lustre (marketed as "early-strike coins")

Furthermore, taller die and hob sets produced for the collector market were discovered, despite the fact that they would not fit into the mint's coin press, while the hobs were not used in the production process, only to create fake dies! The mint removed copyright markings from the real dies for the MMC line, but incorrect dates were added to the dies when the fakes were created, while real dies with the incorrect dates were used to strike additional coins for the collector market.

Other cautionary tales involved posters and autographs, pre-production figures and modern prototypes. Also, vintage-bagged figures either in resealed or re-taped bags, as well as sealed in non-authentic bags with no logo or text on, and even printed logos and text to replicate authentic examples.

When it comes to protection and recourse, here are some tips on what to do:
  • Participate in a collecting community to build friendships and network with other collectors
  • Don't be afraid to speak to others in the community to discuss concerns or alarming trends
  • Online forums and Facebook groups have certain community standards
  • Buy from trusted collectors, dealers or sources
  • Do your research before you buy
  • Legal action as a last resort, since it is expensive, time-consuming and can yield uncertain results

The Emperor's Royal Guard, sponsored by James Gallo and Mark Salotti, was the Star Tot given out at this panel.
Related Articles
April 27, 2017  Celebration Orlando 2017 Collecting Track: Time Travel To Toy Factories Around The World
April 25, 2017  Celebration Orlando 2017 Collecting Track: A Collector's Journey
April 24, 2017  Celebration Orlando 2017 Collecting Track: Vintage Theatrical Advertising And Collectible Ephemera
April 20, 2017  Celebration Orlando 2017 Collecting Track: Hallmark Collectibles
April 19, 2017  Celebration Orlando 2017 Collecting Track: Social Media And Networking
April 18, 2017  Celebration Orlando 2017 Collecting Track: The Star Wars Funko Pop! Vinyl Explosion
April 16, 2017  Celebration Orlando 2017: Sunday's Collecting Track Panels
April 15, 2017  Celebration Orlando 2017: Saturday's Collecting Track Panels
April 14, 2017  Celebration Orlando 2017: Friday's Collecting Track Panels
April 13, 2017  Celebration Orlando 2017: Thursday's Collecting Track Panels
April 10, 2017  Celebration Orlando 2017: All The Collecting Track Star Tots Revealed!

2018 International Toy Fair Coverage
NEW IN THE PHOTO ARCHIVE:
Probe
Droid
Poll
April 13th, 2018, the big day for Lucasfilm's International Solo: A Star Wars Story product launch. Our reprogrammed Imperial Probe Droid has been tasked to see where all the stuff is. You can help by let it know how successful the day was for you.
I found everything in one store!
I found everything, but over many stores.
I found some stuff at one place.
I found some stuff at a few places.
I found next to nothing.
I didn't see a single product on the shelves anywhere.
I bought everything online.
I didn't bother getting anything.
Current Results